Selling Antiques: eBay vs Specialist Buyers

When selling antiques and collectibles, most people end up choosing between listing on eBay and selling to a specialist buyer. Both routes can work, but they suit different situations.

Selling on eBay

Pros

• You set your own price
• Large audience of potential buyers
• Good for common, well-known items
• Auction format can drive prices up for rare items

Cons

• Fees add up - eBay charges listing fees plus a final value fee (typically 12-13% of the sale price)
• PayPal/payment fees - Additional 2-3% processing fee
• Time-consuming - Photography, writing descriptions, managing questions, packaging, and posting
• Risk of scams - Buyer claims and returns can be costly
• No guarantee of sale - Items may not sell, and you have paid listing fees regardless
• Shipping risk - You are responsible for items during transit

Selling to a Specialist Buyer

Pros

• Zero fees - No listing fees, no commission, no hidden charges
• Expert valuations - Specialists may identify value you would miss
• Direct process - Send items, receive offer, get paid
• Same-day payment - No waiting for auctions to end
• Insured postage - Items are covered from the moment they leave your hands
• No risk - Free returns if you decline the offer

Cons

• You might get less than an auction peak price for highly sought-after items
• Less control over the final price

When to Use Each Option

Use eBay when:

• You have time to manage listings
• Your item is well-known and easily searchable
• You are comfortable with the fees and risks
• You enjoy the selling process

Use a specialist buyer when:

• You want quick, hassle-free payment
• You have multiple items to sell
• You are not sure what your items are worth
• You want zero risk and zero fees
• You have inherited items and want everything handled in one go

The Bottom Line

For many sellers, a specialist buyer offers the best balance of speed, simplicity, and reduced risk. The fees saved compared with eBay often offset at least part of any difference in final price.

Get your free postal pack and see what your items are worth, with no obligation.